But first, a quick note:
As an unofficial requirement to be considered for a position, I decided that a player must have been the primary player in that spot for at least one season. For example: Kevin Millar played 425 innings in rightfield in 2004. He played 512 innings at first base. He is listed as the primary first baseman for the Sox that year, but Gabe Kapler actually played 165 more innings in right, so he's the 2004 rightfielder. (Conceivably, a player could qualify at two positions. Conversely, a player who played almost every game might not be the most common guy at any position.) Essentially, I wanted there to be some guidelines here so that I could avoid controversies like, "Rick Cerone played a game in rightfield in 1989. He should have been one of your backup outfielders!" Imagine that being said by a nerd wagging his finger high in the air while pushing his wire frame glasses further up the bridge of his nose. Were you imagining me doing that? I thought so.
Starting Rightfielder: Dwight Evans
For eight of the first ten years of my life, Dwight Evans was the regular rightfielder for the Sox (not to mention seven of eight seasons before I was born). The other two seasons in my date range, Evans qualified as a first baseman or designated hitter (1987 and 1990, respectively). I could inundate you with dozens of stats illustrating why Dewey is the best regular rightfielder the Sox may ever have had. And I think I will. 379 homers in Boston (his six with Baltimore put him three dingers ahead of Hall of Famer Jim Rice's total), 1337 walks (an OBP of .369 to Rice's .352), a career OPS that is higher than Carl Yastrzemski's and 1643 strikeouts! Nobody has gone down swinging more times in a Red Sox uniform than Dwight Michael Evans. Jason Varitek could still make a play for that record, though. Evans has played rightfield in more games than any Sox player ever - by 481 games. He was also a stellar defensive player, had a bitchin' mustache and made my mom swoon. His games as color commentator last season, during Jerry Remy's hiatus, painted him to be a really humble and classy guy to boot. For all these reasons and more, Dewey rules this position with an iron fist and a cannon arm.Backup Outfielder: Jim Rice
Before you scoff at this choice, it is worth noting that the 1980's Jim Rice was not eligible to be the team's starting rightfielder. Let's face it, the Red Sox have had some decent outfielders over the last thirty seasons. Jim has nothing to be ashamed of for being the team's fifth outfielder. Furthermore, Rice's best years were more than behind him by the time I started paying attention as a kid. The Rice of 1988 and 1989, hobbling out to the plate to, maybe, hit one of his 18 home runs from that period, wasn't overly impressive to a seven-year-old. In fact, I was probably just praying that he'd get on base in one of those DH at-bats, which he did 31.4% of the time. Any way you look at it, though, the pre-JMR Jim Rice averaged 32 homers and 109 RBI; his 1981 and beyond counterpart averaged 21 home runs and 87 runs batted in. I'm not hatin' on Jim Rice at all, but I sort of prefer Dewey.In The Minors Rightfielder: Trot Nixon
What can you say about Trot Nixon? Seriously, I could use some help on this one. It's like that misquote I've heard: "I don't know what makes a great rightfielder, but I know what I like." I like Trot. I rooted for him to succeed ever since I first heard about him (which was probably when I was 12 or 13). In fact, aside from Greg Blosser, Trot was one of the first real prospects that I remember knowing. It seemed to take him forever to get to Boston (five years before he showed up to stay after being taken seventh overall in 1993). When he did arrive, everybody was pumped. His name was Trot, he looked homely and a little smelly, he loved putting up the Trot Nixon line in the boxscore (that's 1-for-4 with a walk). And hell, his three peak years (2001-2003), the guy averaged 26 homers, a .396 OBP and his OPS was north of .880 (the .975 OPS of '03 was particularly delicious; man, best lineup ever that year). Somebody on my forty-man roster has to toil out in rightfield down at Pawtucket. What better candidate than Trot Nixon?40-MAN ROSTER
StartersC -
1B -
2B -
3B -
SS - Nomar Garciaparra
LF -
CF -
RF - Dwight Evans
DH -
SS/3B - John Valentin
LF/DH - Jim Rice
SS - Luis Rivera
RF - Trot Nixon